Converting Yeast to Sourdough

Just had an email from Jeff, a recent student, saying that his breadmaking had really come on since doing the course. Feedback like that always cheers me up greatly but this time I also felt a pang of guilt. Why? because I said I’d covert his favourite recipe to sourdough and several weeks later it still wasn’t finished.

Basically converting yeasted to sourdough simply means deducting equal weights of flour and water such that the combined weight of the deduction equals around 30% of the remaining flour in the dough. The weight of the deduction becomes the weight of the starter in the new formula. Gorrit?

Simple example. You have a yeasted bread formula:
Flour: 575g
Water: 375g
Salt: 10g
+ some yeast which we will ignore
Total: 960g

Subtract 75g from the flour weight and 75g from the water = 150g. Your new formula becomes:
Flour: 500g – 100%
Water: 300g – 60%
Starter: 150g – 30%
Salt: 10g – 2.0%
Total: 960g

Notes: This is bakers’ percentage where the other ingredients are percentages of the flour weight which is always 100%. This assumes starter at 100% hydration (equal weights of flour and water). The percentage of starter in a bread formula can be what you want it to be – around 30% is what I consider “normal”. Obviously you have to diddle about a bit to work out how much flour and water will make up 30% of the remaining flour weight. Making yourself a spreadsheet calculator is a big help.

Jeff’s formula wasn’t so straightforward:
Strong Bread Flour: 100g
Wholemeal Wheat: 200g
Rye: 200g
Water: 320g
Salt: 11g
Mixed Seed: 100g

Complicating factors: I think the seed was Jeff’s addition to the original recipe. They were added unsoaked, so the seed was drawing water out of the recipe which made it under-hydrated. Most of the white flour had to be removed for the starter which I think unbalanced the formula – even though it was returned to the dough as fermented flour.

My first attempt was not good because I tried to stick as closely as possible to the original and, despite adding additional water as I went along, it came out too dry and dense.

For the second go I soaked the seed in advance and increased the water too much.

Finally yesterday, spurred on by Jeff’s email, I produced something I was happy with and retitled it Torth Baradwys (he’ll know why):
bara 003 smallStrong Bread Flour: 102g – 26.5%
Wholemeal Wheat: 146g – 36.7%
Rye: 146g – 36.7%
Water: 269g – 70.0%
Starter: 105g – 27.3%
Salt: 7g – 1.8%
Soaker Water: 87g – 22.6%
Seed: 87g – 22.6%

The seed (poppy, golden linseed, sunflower, pumpkin, sesame) is soaked in boiling water and cooled.

Usual method: short kneads; ferment 4 hours with folds at the end of each hour (3); shape, prove 3 1/2 hours. Bake 50 minutes at 210C.

Also yesterday, a beautifully unruly Pane Pugliese:
pug 001 smallpugcrumb 001 smallAnd finally, for those people who still think “artisan” bread has to be full of large holes, a side-by-side comparison:
2crumbs smallBoth are “correct” for the type of bread.

Categories: Uncategorized

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.